World Trip Reports

Tick or not tick?



Hi all,
I am of the opinion that it is up to each individual to please themselves how they make their list. However ,what seems to be the consensus on the following birds?
1 Siberian Stonechat
2 Madeiran Chaffinch
3 Mealy Redpoll
Cheers Tony


[QUOTE=tony.hetheringt]
1 Siberian Stonechat
2 Madeiran Chaffinch
3 Mealy Redpoll
[/QUOTE]

1) Not sure. I think in recent years the "clinching" ID criteria has been challenged quite strongly. Probably best left lumped as a Stonechat for now.
2) No idea.
3) Should definitely be lumped. And I cannot wait for it to happen because I am completely & utterly crap at IDing them.

Tom.



Click here to read entire thread and the replies to this message!

Back to Home Page!